Documentary

9/11 documentaries: watching the day and what followed

Four 9/11 documentaries, from the Naudet brothers' firehouse film to Turning Point, with notes on archive ethics and on watching them with teenagers. Some links here are affiliate links.

9/11 documentaries: watching the day and what followed
In this piece (9 parts)
  1. The day, briefly
  2. The 9/11 documentary filmed by accident
  3. 102 Minutes That Changed America (2008)
  4. Turning Point: 9/11 and the War on Terror (2021)
  5. Fahrenheit 9/11 (2004)
  6. Four films, side by side
  7. Archive and the dead: questions to bring
  8. Watching 9/11 documentaries with teenagers
  9. Reading alongside

Every teenager now was born years after 11 September 2001. For them the day is history, and a 9/11 documentary is often the first place they see it as moving pictures rather than as a date in a textbook. For adults who watched it unfold, the same films do something else. They return us to footage many of us have spent two decades half avoiding.

I have chosen four films that each do one thing well, and I want to be careful about how they do it. This is not a list of the most harrowing footage. It is a guide to films that treat the people in them with respect, with some questions worth asking whenever the record of real deaths becomes material for an edit, and some advice for watching with younger people.

The day, briefly

On the morning of 11 September 2001, nineteen hijackers working for al-Qaeda took control of four passenger planes in the United States. Two were flown into the twin towers of the World Trade Center in New York, one into the Pentagon outside Washington, and the fourth came down in a field in Pennsylvania after passengers fought back. Both towers collapsed within two hours. Nearly 3,000 people were killed.

With American airspace closed, flights bound for the United States were diverted, and many landed in Canada, at Gander, Halifax and other airports. For a lot of Canadians, that is part of how the day is remembered.

The 9/11 documentary filmed by accident

9/11 (2002) began as a different film. Two French brothers, Jules and Gédéon Naudet, were making a documentary about a probationary firefighter at a firehouse in Lower Manhattan, with James Hanlon, a firefighter at that house, as their co-director. On the morning of the attacks, Jules was out with firefighters on a routine call when the first plane passed overhead, and he caught it striking the North Tower, one of very few recordings of that moment. He then followed the firefighters into the tower's lobby. Gédéon stayed behind at the firehouse.

What gives the film its weight is not that shot alone. It is the months before it. We know these men a little before the day arrives, and the film keeps its attention on them, on the work and on the waiting. It is restrained in what it shows, and that restraint is a choice worth noticing, especially by anyone who makes films.

102 Minutes That Changed America (2008)

Made for History, this film is assembled from amateur and archival footage and runs close to real time through the 102 minutes between the first plane striking the North Tower and that tower's collapse. There is no narrator to explain what you are seeing. The effect is to return you to the day's ignorance. Nobody filming knows what is about to happen, and for a while, neither do you.

That is the film's power and its burden. Much of the footage was shot by people who never imagined it would be broadcast, from apartments and streets across the city. Some of the people on screen may not have survived the morning. The film is careful, but you should still ask, as you watch, whether a given shot is witness or spectacle, and whether the film needs it.

Turning Point: 9/11 and the War on Terror (2021)

Brian Knappenberger's series, made for Netflix, treats the attacks as a beginning rather than an end. It moves from the roots of al-Qaeda through the day itself and on into the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the policies at home and abroad that followed, among them surveillance, detention and interrogation. It is the most explanatory of the four: interviews, archive and argument, across several episodes.

It has a point of view, and it is worth noticing whose voices carry it. For older teenagers and adults trying to understand why the day still shapes the world, it is the most useful work here.

Fahrenheit 9/11 (2004)

Michael Moore's film is a polemic, and it announces itself with every edit. It is an argument against the administration of George W. Bush and its war in Iraq, released in an American election year, and it won the Palme d'Or at Cannes. You may agree with it or not. Either way, watch how it persuades: the juxtapositions, the music, the comic timing, the voice-over that tells you what to think of an image before you have finished looking at it.

One choice in it remains, to my mind, among the wisest in any film about the day. Moore handles the attack itself with a darkened screen and sound. Whatever you make of the rest, that refusal to show the impact yet again is worth studying. Fahrenheit 9/11 is a good teaching film about persuasion, and it pairs well with our guide to watching a documentary critically.

Four films, side by side

Film Year Made by Built from With teenagers
9/11 2002 Jules and Gédéon Naudet, with James Hanlon A firehouse film overtaken by the day The most restrained way in, previewed first
102 Minutes That Changed America 2008 Made for History Amateur and archival footage, close to real time Older teens, with an adult beside them
Turning Point: 9/11 and the War on Terror 2021 Brian Knappenberger, for Netflix Interviews, archive and argument Older teens studying the period
Fahrenheit 9/11 2004 Michael Moore Polemic built from archive and interviews Older teens, as a lesson in persuasion

Archive and the dead: questions to bring

The images of that morning were broadcast around the world as they happened, and every documentary that uses them now makes choices on behalf of people who cannot be asked. Some of the most widely seen photographs show people falling from the towers, and many filmmakers have decided not to use such images at all. Recordings of phone calls from the buildings and the planes have been played in some broadcasts and films, and families have felt very differently about that.

Bring these questions to any 9/11 documentary:

  1. Who shot this, and did they expect it to be seen?
  2. Could anyone identifiable on screen have died that morning, and does the film need this shot to make its point?
  3. Is sound being used to do what the film has chosen not to show?
  4. Is each clip placed in time and space, or used as mood?
  5. Who gave permission, and who could not?

Our guide to archive footage and rights explains the licensing side. The ethical side is never settled by a licence alone.

Watching 9/11 documentaries with teenagers

Watch the film yourself first, all of it. You will know where the hard moments are, and you will be calmer when they come.

Start with context rather than footage: a map of Lower Manhattan, the timeline of the morning, who the hijackers were and who was killed. Then choose the film for the young person in front of you, not for the curriculum. The Naudet film is the most restrained, and for many families the best way in, though even it should be previewed. 102 Minutes is intense precisely because it withholds explanation, so it suits older teens with an adult close by. Turning Point is for students who want to understand the wars and policies that followed, and Fahrenheit 9/11 works best as a lesson in argument, watched alongside something that disagrees with it.

Pause often, and let them leave the room if they need to. Ask what they noticed about who made the film and why. Remember, too, that some teenagers carry this history personally. For many Muslim and Sikh families in North America, the years after brought suspicion and abuse, and a classroom conversation can land very differently for them. If the films lead somewhere else, toward how a disaster looks when it is filmed by the people inside it, our guide to Hurricane Katrina documentaries is a good next step.

Reading alongside

The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright is a history of the road to the attacks, and it won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction. It supplies what films about the day cannot: the decades of ideas, people and missed warnings that led there. It earns its place on its published reviews and its long life on reading lists.

If you watch only one film with a teenager, make it the Naudet brothers' 9/11. Then switch it off and ask what they would want to know about the firefighters in it. The answers are usually where the real conversation begins.