Documentary / Culture

What a critic owes the people in a documentary

What a documentary critic owes the real people on screen: review the film not the person, keep what the film kept hidden, and correct every mistake openly. Some links here are affiliate links.

What a critic owes the people in a documentary
In this piece (7 parts)
  1. Review the film, not the person
  2. Keep what the film kept hidden
  3. Spoilers when the plot is a life
  4. Criticizing the ethics without piling on
  5. What happened next
  6. Getting it wrong, and saying so
  7. The rules I keep

Every documentary critic has written some version of this sentence. The kitchen was cluttered. The father seemed vain. The young woman in the second act was hard to like. In a review of a drama, those remarks would be about choices made by a production designer, a screenwriter and an actor. In a review of a documentary they are about a real kitchen, a real father and a real young woman, who will very likely read what was said about them, perhaps years later, perhaps after a cousin sends the link.

Critics of non-fiction work under a double obligation. We owe readers an honest account of the film. We also owe something smaller, though far from trivial, to the people the film is made of. They agreed to be filmed. They never agreed to be reviewed.

What follows is my attempt to say what that second debt amounts to. It comes from a long time spent writing about films in which people lost children, homes, countries and, sometimes, their privacy for good.

Review the film, not the person

The most useful distinction I know is between a person and their portrayal. A documentary subject on screen is a selection: ninety minutes chosen from a hundred hours, cut to an argument, lit, framed and scored. When a subject seems cold, the honest question is how the film made them seem cold. Was the warm scene cut? Is the camera always a little too close at the worst moments? Does the music lean against them?

None of this is a way to dodge judgement. Films judge people, and critics should judge how films do it. But the verb belongs to the filmmaker. "The film presents him as evasive" is a sentence about craft and decisions. "He is evasive" is a sentence about a man I have never met, assembled from whatever an editor let me see of him.

Appearance is the clearest case. A subject's weight, teeth, clothes, accent, furniture or grammar are not material for a review unless the film turns them into an argument, and even then the review should address the argument. Wit at a subject's expense is the cheapest thing in criticism. It costs the critic nothing and the subject a good deal.

Keep what the film kept hidden

When a documentary blurs a face, alters a voice or changes a name, it makes a promise on behalf of everyone who watches. Critics receive that promise early, often months before the public, and we are well placed to break it by accident.

The ways are mundane. A press kit may carry details the final cut removed, such as a first name, a town or an employer. A screener can run longer than the release version. A thank-you in the end credits may name someone the film itself kept anonymous. A publicity still may show a reflection, a licence plate or a street corner that the edit carefully avoided. None of that gives me permission to print anything. If the film withheld a detail, I withhold it, and when I cannot tell whether something is identifying, I leave it out. A review loses nothing by being vague about where a woman who fled violence now lives.

Speculation is the other danger. A reviewer who writes that a disguised witness sounds like some known figure, or who guesses at the city behind a blurred skyline, has done the opposite of criticism. The methods filmmakers use to hide people, and the ways those methods fail, are set out in our guide to consent, safety and anonymity when filming survivors. Critics should read it as closely as producers do. We handle some of the same material, and we can leak it just as easily.

Spoilers when the plot is a life

Spoiler etiquette was invented for fiction, and it fits documentary badly. In a thriller, the twist belongs to the writer. In a documentary about a man's two years in addiction treatment, the ending is whether he relapsed, and that belongs to him.

I still avoid giving away how a film resolves, partly for the usual reason. Many documentaries are built to be discovered in sequence, and a viewer who knows where things land watches differently. The stronger reason is that an outcome stated flatly in the third paragraph of a review becomes the first thing strangers know about a person. She does not get the job. The marriage ends. He dies before the edit is finished. Sentences like these are true of films somewhere, and each one turns a life into a plot point when printed carelessly.

So my test is necessity. If I cannot make my argument without the outcome, I give it, warn the reader first and state it as plainly and kindly as I can. If the argument survives without it, the outcome stays in the cinema.

Criticizing the ethics without piling on

Some films deserve hard words about how they treated people. Consent that looks thin, a vulnerable person filmed in crisis with no sign of care, a hidden camera that seems to have served the crew more than the story: these are fair subjects for a review. A critic who avoids them for fear of seeming harsh is failing readers.

The trouble is that every criticism of a film's ethics passes through its subjects on the way out. If I write that a film exploited a grieving family, I have also described that family as exploited, to readers who may go looking for them. Online, a review is the first link in a long chain of reposts and comment threads, and the people at the far end of that chain are seldom the filmmakers.

A few habits help. Aim every objection at a decision, and name who made it: the director, the editor, the broadcaster that commissioned the series. Do not quote a subject's worst moment back to readers as proof; describe it in a sentence and move on. Never illustrate the review with a still from the scene you object to, because the image will outlive the argument. And resist turning the review into its own spectacle of outrage, which only spreads the harm around. Measured sentences carry further than angry ones, in my experience, and they are far less likely to land on the wrong person.

What happened next

Documentary subjects keep living after the credits, and critics are often tempted to report what has happened to them since. Sometimes the film does this itself with a closing title card. Sometimes the press notes do. Sometimes a quick search turns up an arrest, a death or a lawsuit, and the temptation becomes a reflex.

My rule is that later events belong in a review only when they change how the film should be understood, and only when they sit on the public record in a form the person would recognize as public. Someone who later became a public figure, or who has spoken openly about life since the film, has in a sense invited the update. Kim Phuc, who has lived for more than fifty years alongside a single photograph and has spoken about that life in public many times, is the clearest example I know. A teenager filmed at sixteen who has since gone quietly back to ordinary life has invited nothing. A critic who digs up her employer or her court date has slipped into reporting without any of reporting's safeguards.

When an update is necessary, check it twice, say where it comes from and keep it short. A film is a fixed object. A life is not, and a review that pins someone to their lowest moment inflicts a second injury.

Getting it wrong, and saying so

Critics make factual mistakes about real people more often than we like to admit. A misremembered name, a relationship misread, a sibling described as a spouse, a remark attributed to the wrong speaker in a crowded film. In a review of a drama, a slip like that is embarrassing. In a review of a documentary it places a false fact on the public record about someone who never chose to be written about.

The remedy is simple and should be done in the open. Correct the error promptly, add a dated note saying what was wrong, and leave the note where readers can see it. A silent edit looks tidier and helps nobody, because the wrong version has already been read, quoted and copied. If a subject writes to me about a review, I read the message slowly and assume, until I have good reason to think otherwise, that they know their own life better than I do. Opinions I stand by. Facts I fix.

The rules I keep

These sit on an index card above my desk. They are not a code anyone else has to adopt, and they have never stopped me writing a hard review. What they stop is a careless one.

  1. Describe people by what they do in the film, never by how they look or speak.
  2. Give every criticism a maker: the director, the editor, the commissioning channel.
  3. Never print an identifying detail the film withheld, wherever I happened to find it.
  4. Do not guess who a disguised person might be, or where they might live.
  5. Reveal how a life turns out only when the review cannot work without it, and warn first.
  6. Mention later events only when they change the film's meaning and are plainly public.
  7. Correct factual errors openly, with a date, and never by quiet edit.
  8. Before filing, read the review once as if I were the person in it.

The last rule takes about four minutes and catches more than the other seven combined. Read from inside that cluttered kitchen, most of the easy sentences at the top of this page would never reach print. None of this makes a review softer. The questions in how to watch a documentary critically still apply in full, and a film that mistreats its subjects should hear about it from us. But the person on screen ought to finish my review no worse off than the film left them. So I read it once more from their side of the table, slowly, before I let it go.